In 1998 I purchased a Sony MZ-R50 minidisc rather than buying an MP3 player, as the minidisc allowed me to record 74 minutes in stereo or a whopping 148 minutes in mono on a single disc, which cost around $10, which was a capacity way beyond any MP3 player of comparable pricing at the time. At the end of 2005, however, MP3 player technology has reached a stage of maturity where it has become commonplace and has largely supplanted previous forms such as the ubiquitous tape walkman, the CD discman, and less common minidisc. Devotees no longer swap tapes, they swap files and folders.
Here’s a redux of various MP3 player brands and technologies that I am familiar with, along with my experiences and analysis.
Let me mention a few factors that you can use in comparing players:
- Features - here is a feature list that I consider necessary: built-in microphone, line-encoding (for ripping to mp3 from a mixing desk or walkman), support for ogg (free format).
- Hard Disk or Flash-based. Hard Disk has more storage space, but is bigger and bulkier. Flash is smaller and more energy efficient, but has less storage space.
- Battery life. The longer the better, obviously. Built-in Lithium-ion or Lithium polymer batteries are cheaper and more convenient as you don’t have to keep buying batteries or carrying around a recharger. The disadvantage is that when they go flat right before a class you can’t put in a spare one.
- Connector - a built-in USB connector is great. A USB cable that you have to lug around is not so good. An adaptor to plug into the unit to connect a separate cable to is a nightmare.
- Size and weight. If you are going to be carrying this thing around with you to listen to music and lectures on, the smaller and lighter the better. The trade-off can sometimes be durability, or features (including storage space).
- Obviously price - and you should do a calculation of the features per price, but remember - whatever you spend is completely wasted if the thing ends up as a paperweight because it doesn’t do what you need, and don’t be fooled by a “cheap” price that actually includes your time spent dealing with its foibles.
Let’s start with the most popular and highest profile mp3 player: the Apple iPod.
Apple iPod / iPod Nano / Photo iPod / Video iPod
Link
This unit sets the standard for design and cool. According to my Universal Principles of Design book, aesthetic design contributes to a sense of ease of use, and that’s definitely a factor with the Apple iPod. However, it has one area of weakness, and that is that it is a unit designed for consumers. The idea is that you buy songs from the iTunes online music store and download them to your iPod. The unit has no built-in production, that is to say recording, capability. For devotees, who are interested in recording classes, conversations, and kirtans for later review and distribution, it’s a critical area of weakness.
You can get a third party add-on from Belkin to enable the iPod to record. However, the strengths of the iPod and its focus do not lie in this area, which is a pretty crucial area for devotees, who are not catered to by the existing system of content creation and distribution that the iPod is designed as an integral part of.
Personally I would view the iPod as incompatible with the standard devotee lifestyle for this reason. It’s strengths lie in areas that are irrelevant or even detrimental to devotee lifestyle, and in areas where the need is greatest - in recording new content to supplant the current cultural output - it is sadly deficient.
That’s not to say that don’t think it’s a cool device with a great design - for what it is.
iRiver H-series
Link

This machine seems to be the devotee workhorse. The H-120 and H-140, with 20GB and 40GB hard drives respectively, were the first generation of player / recorders. The H-340, with a color LCD, is the current model. This machine is solid engineering - of sturdy construction, well built, with a well designed interface, good feature set, and good post-release support.
The H-120/140 has optical in and out (not that you ever use it, but it’s practically unique in the market space for this feature). Optical in/out allows pure digital transfer to and from machines such as hard disk multi track recording systems, minidisc decks, DAT units, and other high-end audio equipment. Not much use for anyone except those who are doing specific high end stuff using old gear that doesn’t support USB transfer of digital data. I’m not sure if the H320/340 still has this - but you can live without it. However, it demonstrates the engineering of this unit.
I skipped over this unit, even though others around me bought it, for a couple of reasons. One is the size of the unit. It’s feature packed and solid, but also chunky. It will definitely last a long time. Looking back, if I had to make the decision again, I might make it differently, but maybe not. Carrying that thing around in my pocket for the last year would have been a trip.
This thing has what you need - built-in microphone for “voice recording” (read classes, kirtans, etc…), line-in encoding, which you use to hook the unit up to a mixing desk or stereo output to capture classes or convert old tapes / records to mp3. It also handles a variety of formats - mp3, wma (yuck!), and the awesome, free format ogg.
The H-140 has a battery life of around 12 hours. For a general hard disk based solution this is a good one, when you think about it from a recording perspective. From a playback perspective, the unit is quite big and heavy, relatively speaking.
All in all, however, for most people this is a good choice. The engineering is excellent and the unit will stand up to some serious bashing. The post-release support is excellent as well, something that I did not factor in when making my original mp3 player purchase.
After the player is released, iRiver continue to develop the firmware for it, and release new functionality. After the H-120/140 was released, for example, support was added for ogg and also for deleting files on the player itself. Other mp3 player manufacturers do not continue to develop new functionality, restricting themselves to fixing bugs - for a while. After all, they don’t make more money by putting resources into a unit that you already paid for. iRiver’s commitment to developing the unit even after it has been sold is a major plus.
Recently I got my hands on a new H10 - a 5GB hard disk unit with a color LCD. It is smaller and more portable, and promises a 16 hour battery life. It looks good - the start up time is much faster than the H-140, which is important when you have to start it up and start recording as fast as possible in order to not miss the first few sentences of a class, or the opening of a kirtan.
JNC SSF-M3
Link
This is the unit that I got instead of the iRiver H-120/140. It was at the time the world’s slimmest 20GB mp3 player. I have also seen the 40GB version, which is larger. Between 20GB and 40GB I don’t think you can really tell the difference. Unless you are using it to store DVDs or movie data, you can’t listen to everything on either a 20GB or 40GB player, so the extra weight and size of the 40GB one is not such a good tradeoff.
The main consideration for me in getting this one was the size (along with the necessity of supporting the free format ogg). You carry it around with you all the time, whether you are recording or not. And most of the time you are listening. So the smaller and lighter it is, the better.
It doesn’t have a screen on the unit, or even a full set of controls. It also doesn’t have a USB connector or line in on the unit. The screen is in the remote, as are the full set of controls, and the USB connection and line in are on a small adaptor or a base station that comes with the unit.
This is a strength and a weakness. If you lose or break the remote then the unit becomes essentially worthless. You have to carry around the adaptor to get access to all the functionality of the unit.
The main strength of this unit is the size. You can slip this thing in your pocket and forget about it. You can’t do that with an iRiver. The headache is in carrying around the adaptor as well as the cable.
The JNC doesn’t have the ability to delete files from the unit itself, needing to be connected to a computer to do this. JNC also don’t do much in the way of post-release engineering of the firmware.
iRiver T20
The iRiver T20 is an example of a flash-based mp3 player / recorder. Flash players have lower capacities than hard disk ones. If you have a laptop computer with a large hard drive you can often store your library there, and transfer files to and from your flash based player, rather than lugging around your entire library on a hard drive. After all, you can’t listen to 20 GB of mp3s at once.
The T20 has 1GB of storage and what I would consider a good mix of features, with iRiver’s solid engineering. It has a slide out USB connector, line-encoding, plays ogg, built-in microphone, good eq (including user definable), can delete files and folders from the player itself (doesn’t need to be connected to a computer) with the latest firmware. It’s very small and lightweight (about as big as a Bic lighter) and has up to 14 hour battery life.
iRiver do great engineering. They build things that are robust and very usable. Their units are solidly engineered, not at all flimsy or whimsical, and the feature set of their hardware and firmware is great.
Weaknesses: it needs Windows in order to upgrade the firmware (you have to use their software to do it - which doesn’t run on Mac or Linux), and also to order the tracks - they don’t play in alphabetical order on the device.
Compared with JNC’s 1GB SSF-5100 the T20 has a Lithium Polymer battery built-in (which recharges via USB) to the JNC’s AAA removable battery, 14 hours battery life ot the JNC’s 9, support for mp3, wma, and ogg to the JNC’s mp3 and wma, and iRiver’s proven post-release firmware support.
Sony
Link
Sony make some of the best engineered gear, with the smartest features. My MZ-R50 minidisc is still going strong almost 8 years later (the MZ-R50 is considered to be the best model they made). The Li-Ion battery is still going strong, and I use the built-in compressor and microphone preamp to go into the line-in on an mp3 recorder.
The Sony NW-HD5, for example, has a whopping 40 hour battery life on its Li-Ion powerpack.
However, I would not recommend buying Sony because of their corporate stance on consumer freedom - they don’t believe it. For example, later versions of the MZ series of minidiscs had USB transfer capability - but you could not transfer digitally from one MD recorder to your computer, and then to another MD recorder. The idea there is to stop people from “pirating” Sony’s proprietary copyrighted content, for example by putting Sony Artist X on your MD, then your computer, then a mate’s MD. What it does in effect is effect is stop you from recording a kirtan or class on your MD, and then digitally transferring to anyone else.
Forget it.
The NW-HD5 does not support the free format ogg. Sony uses a compression technology called ATRAC3, which is technologically brilliant - smaller filesizes than mp3, but completely controlled by Sony, and even more restrictive than mp3. They only allow it to be interacted with using their proprietary software interfaces. The recent scandal involving Sony copy-protected music discs installing root kits on Windows machines shows the ridiculously extreme restrictions on consumer freedoms that they like to impose. I don’t recommend buying Sony at all, in spite of their technical and engineering brilliance, for those reasons.
Less is More
Whether you opt for a small lightweight player / recorder with a few hundred megs of RAM, or a full-on multi-gigabyte hard disk player / recorder will depend on your usage, and also the other gear you have. One thing that I’ve noticed is that you can’t listen to everything on even a 20GB unit. I used to joke when comparing my 20GB with other devotees who had 40GB units - “40GB? Anything above 20GB is atyahara (overcollecting)!” While I was in Peru, Raivata lent me his 64MB Diva mp3 player. I could put only one kirtan from Harer Nama and one class at a time from the Contemporary Urban Preaching Seminars. I can play that kirtan verbatim on harmonium, accordion, and mrdanga, and I can give that seminar verbatim. That’s the power of concentration. With a 40GB unit you can have every recorded Prabhupada class in one place - but will you be able to listen to them?
Gone are the days of having one tape and playing it until it weared out. Now you can grab gigabytes of lectures and kirtans from other devotees, all in one hit.
Less is more. I’ve now gone backwards to a lower spec’d mp3 player - trading off storage space for size and speed (it’s flash based). It forces me to constantly make decisions about what will be on there, as there is simply not enough room to just keep putting all kinds of things on it. That’s a good thing.