Why Was Buddha Successful?

Posted by sita-pati under General View recent posts with the tag General on Technorati 

According to the Gaudiya Vaisnava history, Lord Gautama Buddha, who appeared sometime around 500 BC, was a saktyavesa-avatara, or an empowered incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The purpose of his incarnation was to teach the people upa-dharma, or sub-religious principles.

At the time of his appearance the then current implementation of the Vedic principles had become degraded. It is the nature of this world that everything tends toward decay and disorder. An original vital principle becomes implemented in a specific practice in particular environmental circumstances. This then becomes a doctrine that is preserved for its own sake as the original principles is forgotten.

As an example, there was once a Guru who spoke on the scriptures in the evening. He had a pet cat, which would run and play amongst the crowd while he was speaking. In order to curtail this, he would tie the cat to a tree. After some time that Guru left his body. His disciples continued to speak from the scriptures in that place, and they would tie the cat to the tree. After some more time, the cat left its body. Then they procured another cat and tied that to the tree. After four successive generations, one of the members of that disciplic succession wrote an essay on the venerable tradition of their sect of tying a cat to a tree during scriptural discourses.

That’s simply the nature of this world. Traditions require reformation and renovation, and our own spiritual practice requires it from year to year, and even day to day. We forget about the essence, about why we’re doing things, and start to just go through the motions.

At the time of the appearance of Buddha, the people had become very degraded. In the Vedic system structures are created that allow people to gradually advance from where they are at. Therefore progressive concessionary arrangements and positions were made for meat-eating. These were abused, however, just as marriage, the progressive concessionary position for sex desire, has become abused in the modern age. Therefore Lord Buddha appeared to preach ahimsa, or non-violence, in order to readjust the situation.

So far, so good, standard history as we know it. Now comes the interesting part - how did Buddha manage to get traction with his preaching? If people were into meat-eating, and he came along opposing that, why did people follow him?

The reason is that not only was there widespread killing of animals going on, but the Brahamanas were oppressing and exploiting the people, using the Vedic scriptures as their justification. We often hear that Lord Buddha preached “throw out the Vedic system” because people were killing too many animals on the basis of the Vedas, but what he preached, and what the people responded to was: “throw out the Vedic system because it is being used to oppress you”, and the people said: “Yes!”

He was able to encourage them to a non-violent lifestyle that was aligned with the real spirit of Vedic human civilization, while throwing out the pseudo-system that justified itself on external adherence to Vedic teaching.

When Sripada Sankaracarya forced Buddhism out of India in the 9th century AD, we usually think that he forcefully preached the doctrine of the Vedas with a nirvisesa (impersonalist) conclusion that resembled the sunyavada doctrine evolved in Buddhism. That is what he did, but how he did it, is that he got the support of the now weakened and irrelevant Brahmana class by basing his preaching on the Vedic scriptures, and he got the support of the people by preaching that one can become a brahmana no matter what his family background, if he is qualified to act as one (guna-karma vibhagasah).

(Sripada Sankaracarya took sannyasa at the age of 8, and left his body at the age of 33, by the way.)

Again, by the time of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, the situation had deteriorated to one of debauchery in the name of Vedic injunctions, and caste brahmanism. Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, while preaching His divine message of Love of God, reached out to and connected with, validated, and empowered socially excluded and marginalized groups, as exemplified in his relationship with Haridasa Thakura, born in a Muslim family and considered “untouchable” by the standards of orthodox Hindus of the day.

Srila Bhaktivinode Thakura, Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati, and Srila Prabhupada did the same thing, with Srila Prabhupada going outside India and for the first time demonstrating on a large scale that non-Hindus (people outside the geographical boundaries of India) can apply the Vedic principles, and that a Vedic framework can adapt to their environment.

So we can see that these personalities appear when there is a large excluded sector and their preaching gains popular momentum amongst the disenfranchised sectors of society. One of the symptoms of disturbance in the correct social order is when one sector of society unnaturally gains dominance and utilizes the social structure to oppress the other sectors.

As people begin to wake up to the reality of global warming and climate change, and realize that it is not possible to stop it without fundamentally altering the nature of power in society we will see things polarize more and more.

The other day I got a letter from the Australian Conservation Fund asking me for a donation to help fight climate change.

The thing is that climate change is the natural consequence of the current economic structure of the world, which is the result of the dominance of the vaisya mentality - seeing the world as a global marketplace. The only way to halt climate change is to change the structure of society. Most people are comfortably numb these days, but they are beginning to wake up to the impending disaster. After some time their consciousness will rise sufficiently, and their actions to stop the symptoms will lead them close enough to the root causes that they will realize what is going on.

And at that time, we will be ready.

One Response to “Why Was Buddha Successful?”


As a late 2007 update to this piece, another factor in Buddha’s success was that the pseudo-varnasrama system excluded qualified brahmanas from society on the basis of their birth. So all those guys with the leet communications and philosophical skillz were just hanging around waiting for a chance to join the rebel alliance and overthrow the system.

When Sankaracarya changed that aspect of the Hindu presentation, allowing qualified persons to take sannyasa and other leadership position regardless of their birth, he stole that thunder and capitalized on those people himself.

Leave a Reply

You can track future comments on this post via this RSS feed. You can trackback this post by pinging this URL. Allowed HTML: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>



Urban Missionary

Communication >> Krishna Consciousness >> Leadership


    Subscribe to the RSS feed
    Subscribe to the podcast RSS feed



    The Web looks better using the Firefox browser

    Email Updates

    Enter your Email


    Powered by FeedBlitz

    Categories

    General
    Syndicate
    What if…?
    Hare Krishna
    Tech tales
    On Marriage
    Commentary
    Local News
    Inspirational
    Diary
    South American Diary
    Media Watch
    WSN News
    Loft Preaching
    Leadership
    Vision
    Strategy
    People
    Definitions
    Internal
    Bhakti Sastri
    Trends
    Inside the mind of a demon
    Sounds
    Music
    Classes
    podcasts
    Network Centric Preaching
    Book Review
    Sunday Feast preaching
    Sita-pati sez
    Humor
    Realizations
    Harinam Kirtan
    Communicating
    Slideshows
    Atma Yoga
    Yoga Teacher Training
    Climate Change

    Archives

    September 2006 (2)
    August 2006 (12)
    July 2006 (21)
    June 2006 (53)
    May 2006 (34)
    April 2006 (44)
    March 2006 (53)
    February 2006 (38)
    January 2006 (52)
    December 2005 (20)
    November 2005 (36)
    October 2005 (36)
    September 2005 (46)
    August 2005 (90)
    July 2005 (78)
    June 2005 (67)
    May 2005 (60)
    April 2005 (75)
    March 2005 (31)
    February 2005 (37)
    January 2005 (24)
    December 2004 (16)
    November 2004 (28)
    October 2004 (13)
    September 2004 (23)
    August 2004 (39)
    July 2004 (6)

    Use the calendar below to find posts by day (mouseover a day on the calendar to see all posts from that day). If you're looking for a specific post, it's much faster to use the search box above.

    June 2006
    M T W T F S S
    « May   Jul »
     1234
    567891011
    12131415161718
    19202122232425
    2627282930  
  • Guide to this Site

    • About Urban Missionary Start here for information on this site and how to use it
    • Contemporary Urban Preaching Everything you wanted to know about the Loft Preaching Paradigm
    • Good to Great Reviews and articles related to Jim Collins' seminal book
    • Kirtan A collection of articles on instruments, guidelines, and melodies, and mp3 recordings of kirtan and bhajan
    • Leadership Articles, Book reviews and links to resources on Leadership
  • Recent Comments

    pockerstars mac: pockerstars mac... Daly gleans rides bedding.inexpensively unessential ...
    Сергей: Обалдеть просто! Почти все, блин, всё знают,
    a.prakash: i get peace and also some devotion
    jason: erwerfrgrd
    gugukaBest: test gf sdfg sdf gsdfg sdfjkgh sdljkfgh
    vishal: i want photograph to see prahaladadasa
    alexander matenga: this i know to be true
    Диман: Я, хоть и не ваш постоянный читатель,
    XRumerIsTheBest: Доброго времени суток, форумчане сайта www.urbanmissionary.info ;)
    buy cheap tenuate to ret: grecjnl ktgpxch
    Gaura: I play accordion with four fingers it doesnt
    Steve: This is a nice little mix you
    kiki: God created them male and female. God
    Radhika: Hi I watch the movie. i think
    lznyaouvg psudcjvy: mrkh leihfmju gamvs xnhpbm jbwldz mijurl ahcpvykz
    slot 1: slot 1... affirmatively Camille Monica dreadfully ...
    hwpsl bdukpstni: lpkxjgrwm gluwjvpio qfhigj tusexlra yrafib qcxkn qvmdyo
    jereme: Dandavats,this is great. Really useful for devotees
    Locations of visitors to this page

    Creative Commons License
    This site is licensed in alignment with the Vedic tradition under a Creative Commons license - specifically this one.
    Quote Urban Missionary at will. Inbound links are appreciated, and required for direct quotations.