Srila Prabhupada - A Friend to All

Posted by sita-pati under Book Review View recent posts with the tag Book Review on Technorati 

Today I’m sitting the RHCE exam, in ten minutes in fact.

I’ve been reading “Our Srila Prabhupada - A Friend to All: Early Contemporaries Remember Him“.

It is a very interesting book. It is a collection of interviews with persons who knew Srila Prabhupada before he left India to preach in the West. From reading this book and hearing their appreciations I’ve gained a greater appreciation for the point of view of Srila Prabhupada’s godbrothers, the Gaudiya Math, Srila BV Narayana Maharaja, and other persons who hold a different angle of vision than I have.

Even within ISKCON everyone has a different angle of vision.

Reading this book I can understand and appreciate why Srila BV Narayana Maharaja sees things the way he does. That doesn’t mean that I abandon my own unique perspective, but I can appreciate the difference. The ability to simultaneously accomodate diverse, and sometimes contradictory viewpoints is important. The whole Vedic culture is based on this, and the inability of modern Western academics to appreciate this aspect of it leads them to interpret it as a confusion or collection of competing systems. In fact, there are many different people in society, each with their own unique and valid experience.

The Vedic culture recognizes and honours this by constructing a situation where these people can coexist and pursue their own self realization and spiritual evolution in such a way that the impact of their angle of vision on others with a different angle of vision is minimized. This is done by the guidance of brahmanas, spiritually adept persons who are able to accomodate and appreciate multiple angles of vision and interact with people in terms of their mentality.

A lot of the time people of different mentalities are encouraged to stick to their own concerns, and ignore others around them, as they will find the plethora of mentalities and realizations confusing, and will react by either becoming attracted to something that they shouldn’t, or condemning something that they shouldn’t.

The Srimad Bhagavatam describes this principle of multiple angles of vision:

“Steadiness in one’s own position is declared to be actual piety, whereas deviation from one’s position is considered impiety. In this way the two are definitely ascertained.”

SB. 11.21.2

His Holiness Hrdayananda Goswami, commenting on this, says:

In actuality, virtue and fault are not absolute but are relative to one’s particular platform of advancement. Remaining fixed in the type of discrimination suitable to one’s level of advancement is good, and anything else is bad.

So people are encouraged to focus their attention on cultivating their own progress, and not to give much attention to what other people are doing, which can often lead to misunderstanding, and offense.

In the case of Srila Prabhupada and his disciples, they were encouraged to be busy about their own work, so much so that they didn’t have time to poke their nose into what other Gaudiya Vaisnavas were doing. This was Srila Prabhupada’s practical way of “keeping the children apart”.

How easy misunderstanding comes about is described in one pastime I read last night (I’ll get the reference later).

Many of us are familiar with Srila Prabhupada’s eulogy to his sannyasa guru,Srila Bhakti Prajnana Kesava Maharaja, who left his body while Srila Prabhupada was in America.

What we didn’t know was the back story. Srila Prabhupada was writing letters to Trivikrama Maharaja, Srila Kesava Maharaja’s disciple, asking him why he wasn’t sending the mrdangas he had promised to send. Trivikrama Maharaja and the other disciples were of course dealing with the impending departure of their gurudeva. They had written to Srila Prabhupada to inform him of Srila Kesava Maharaja’s condition, but those messages had not reached Prabhupada.

Srila Prabhupada is left wondering why these guys are not lending support, and they are left wondering why Srila Prabhupada is so insensitive to the condition of his dear Godbrother and the situation there.

Aspersions are made and things are said which remain for years afterwards, even after the misunderstanding has been cleared up. This book helps to bring some of these things into the light.

There are a number of other incidences where the backstory is explained and the whole situation is laid out. A lot of frictions simply arise from different angles of vision, incomplete understanding, and an inability to hold on to our own understanding while honoring another who has a different understanding.

This book is helping me to understand the perspective of Srila Prabhupada’s Godbrothers, and to understand Srila Prabhupada’s policy of separation. It is in fact necessary to “keep the children apart”.

I’m not about to run off and join the Gaudiya Math (as if it were one homogenous thing and ISKCON were another homogenous thing), but I feel that I have a deeper appreciation for our wider heritage from reading this book, and a deeper appreciation for Srila Prabhupada from other angles of vision.

3 Responses to “Srila Prabhupada - A Friend to All”


Dear Sitapati Prabhu,

I hope you remember me. I am a South American guy (Brasil) in his 50s. I was in Brisbane for a couple of months a couple of years ago. My name is Dayanidhi Dasa but in ISKCON circles I go as bhakta Daniel. I saw you briefly a few months back in Sydney (where I live) for the opening of Govindas Yoga.

I read your blog often. It’s very good! You have a real talent for this kind of medium. I do bloggin too but I spend more time fixing the CSS and the PHP than writing anything. That’s the thing with blogging, you HAVE to have something to say. However, I think I may get better with time.

Anyway, about this review, I agree 100% with you. You really hit the nail on the head, this is a very human, warm and personal book that really shows how flawed is this unfortunate myth that Srila Prabhupada came to the West as a one solitary crusader, leaving behind his “useless, lazy, envious god-brothers, with not preaching inspiration at all”, more ready to criticise him that to help him.

This book shows that Srila Prabhupada was the front line of a Vaisnava culture that was ready to cross the sea and become universal and attractive to the Western spiritual seeker. The book also shows how many people Prabhupada wanted to engage in his preaching, even before the Jaladuta odyssey.

I could even say that this book changed my spiritual life, it made me realise how rich the Vaisnava family tree is.

Best of luck with all endeavours and happy blogging. As Cervantes says in Don Quijote: “ladran Sancho, senial de que caminamos” (dogs are barking, Sancho, a signal we are moving forward).

Leave a Reply

You can track future comments on this post via this RSS feed. You can trackback this post by pinging this URL. Allowed HTML: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>



Urban Missionary

Communication >> Krishna Consciousness >> Leadership


    Subscribe to the RSS feed
    Subscribe to the podcast RSS feed



    The Web looks better using the Firefox browser

    Email Updates

    Enter your Email


    Powered by FeedBlitz

    Categories

    General
    Syndicate
    What if…?
    Hare Krishna
    Tech tales
    On Marriage
    Commentary
    Local News
    Inspirational
    Diary
    South American Diary
    Media Watch
    WSN News
    Loft Preaching
    Leadership
    Vision
    Strategy
    People
    Definitions
    Internal
    Bhakti Sastri
    Trends
    Inside the mind of a demon
    Sounds
    Music
    Classes
    podcasts
    Network Centric Preaching
    Book Review
    Sunday Feast preaching
    Sita-pati sez
    Humor
    Realizations
    Harinam Kirtan
    Communicating
    Slideshows
    Atma Yoga
    Yoga Teacher Training
    Climate Change

    Archives

    September 2006 (2)
    August 2006 (12)
    July 2006 (21)
    June 2006 (53)
    May 2006 (34)
    April 2006 (44)
    March 2006 (53)
    February 2006 (38)
    January 2006 (52)
    December 2005 (20)
    November 2005 (36)
    October 2005 (36)
    September 2005 (46)
    August 2005 (90)
    July 2005 (78)
    June 2005 (67)
    May 2005 (60)
    April 2005 (75)
    March 2005 (31)
    February 2005 (37)
    January 2005 (24)
    December 2004 (16)
    November 2004 (28)
    October 2004 (13)
    September 2004 (23)
    August 2004 (39)
    July 2004 (6)

    Use the calendar below to find posts by day (mouseover a day on the calendar to see all posts from that day). If you're looking for a specific post, it's much faster to use the search box above.

    March 2006
    M T W T F S S
    « Feb   Apr »
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  
  • Guide to this Site

    • About Urban Missionary Start here for information on this site and how to use it
    • Contemporary Urban Preaching Everything you wanted to know about the Loft Preaching Paradigm
    • Good to Great Reviews and articles related to Jim Collins' seminal book
    • Kirtan A collection of articles on instruments, guidelines, and melodies, and mp3 recordings of kirtan and bhajan
    • Leadership Articles, Book reviews and links to resources on Leadership
  • Recent Comments

    pockerstars mac: pockerstars mac... Daly gleans rides bedding.inexpensively unessential ...
    Сергей: Обалдеть просто! Почти все, блин, всё знают,
    a.prakash: i get peace and also some devotion
    jason: erwerfrgrd
    gugukaBest: test gf sdfg sdf gsdfg sdfjkgh sdljkfgh
    vishal: i want photograph to see prahaladadasa
    alexander matenga: this i know to be true
    Диман: Я, хоть и не ваш постоянный читатель,
    XRumerIsTheBest: Доброго времени суток, форумчане сайта www.urbanmissionary.info ;)
    buy cheap tenuate to ret: grecjnl ktgpxch
    Gaura: I play accordion with four fingers it doesnt
    Steve: This is a nice little mix you
    kiki: God created them male and female. God
    Radhika: Hi I watch the movie. i think
    lznyaouvg psudcjvy: mrkh leihfmju gamvs xnhpbm jbwldz mijurl ahcpvykz
    slot 1: slot 1... affirmatively Camille Monica dreadfully ...
    hwpsl bdukpstni: lpkxjgrwm gluwjvpio qfhigj tusexlra yrafib qcxkn qvmdyo
    jereme: Dandavats,this is great. Really useful for devotees
    Locations of visitors to this page

    Creative Commons License
    This site is licensed in alignment with the Vedic tradition under a Creative Commons license - specifically this one.
    Quote Urban Missionary at will. Inbound links are appreciated, and required for direct quotations.